Discover Flagstaff. Find your perfect investment.

The right neighborhood can make or break your investment.

 I get asked all the time: “Jane, where should I buy in Flagstaff?” My answer? It depends on your goals—but let me give you my insider scoop from years of managing rentals and guiding investors.

Top Neighborhoods:

  • Downtown Flagstaff – Vibrant and bustling, this area attracts tourists year-round. My guests love being within walking distance of restaurants, breweries, and shops. STRs here are always in demand.
  • Historic Districts – These charming homes carry a premium, but their uniqueness often translates to higher long-term appreciation. I’ve helped clients find hidden gems here that pay off beautifully.
  • Mountain-View Communities – Perfect for vacationers seeking scenic views. I personally stayed in one as a guest and instantly saw why travelers love it—peaceful, photogenic, and highly rentable.
  • Near Northern Arizona University – Consistent demand from students and staff. Great for investors looking for reliable year-round rental income.

When touring neighborhoods, I always walk the streets, chat with locals, and check out nearby amenities. You get a real feel for the vibe, which you can’t get from listings alone.

Flagstaff’s neighborhoods each tell a story, and the right one can amplify your ROI and your guests’ experience. Explore, ask questions, and don’t underestimate the power of location.